Store Hours
Holiday Hours
Welcome to Play It Again Sports New Hartford, NY!
We buy and sell quality-used sports gear.
We buy and sell quality-used sports gear.
Get paid on the spot, or trade up for the gear you need now. Our staff members are trained to provide athletes with the best possible fit in all categories.
We buy gear all day, every day, with no appointment necessary. Each location is individually owned and operated, so it is easy to support local while shopping sustainably and affordably. Visit our store or shop online!
See what everyone loves about Play It Again Sports - New Hartford, NY!This is a carousel with slides. Use Next and Previous slider arrow buttons to navigate.
Bigger and better than ever!
Bigger and better than ever!
Winning doesn't have seasons and neither do we!
Winning doesn't have seasons and neither do we!
No Appointment Needed!
No Appointment Needed!
HOW WE BUY YOUR GEAR
-
Bring Us Your Gear Bring us any of your gear from our accepted equipment list. We buy all day, every day! Bring Us Your Gear Bring us any of your gear from our accepted equipment list. We buy all day, every day! -
We'll Take a Look We’ll review and research each item and identify a fair market value for your products. While we are doing this, feel free to check out all of the cool used gear in our stores. We'll Take a Look We’ll review and research each item and identify a fair market value for your products. While we are doing this, feel free to check out all of the cool used gear in our stores. -
We'll Make An Offer We will then make you an offer based on that fair market value. If you like the offer, we will pay you on the spot or you can trade against the cool, used gear you find in our stores. *All offers/quotes are subject to thorough testing of the product you are selling to Play It Again Sports. We'll Make An Offer We will then make you an offer based on that fair market value. If you like the offer, we will pay you on the spot or you can trade against the cool, used gear you find in our stores. *All offers/quotes are subject to thorough testing of the product you are selling to Play It Again Sports.
GET REWARDED WHEN YOU SHOP OR SELL! Join Our Text Club
Join Our Text Club
Be the first to know about exclusive deals and events, while racking up points to save you money!
Start Earning Now